Friday, April 24, 2009

Social bookmarks as traces left behind as navigational signposts

Social tagging arose out of the need to organize found content that is worth revisiting. It is natural therefore to think of social tagging and bookmarking as navigational signposts for interesting content. The collective behavior of users who tagged contents seems to offer a good basis for exploratory search interfaces, even for users who are not using social bookmarking sites.

In Boston at the CHI2009 conference, we presented a paper that showed how our tag-based search interface called MrTaggy can be used as learning tools for people to find content relating to a particular topic. We have already announced its availability on this blog, and also touched upon the way in which it is implemented. Here we will briefly blog about an evaluation study we did on this system in order to understand its learning effects.

Short Story:

The tag-based search system allows users to utilize relevance feedback on tags to indicate their interest in various topics, enabling rapid exploration of the topic space. It turns out that the experiment shows that the system seems to provide a kind of scaffold for users to learn new topics.

Long Story:

We recently completed a 30-subject study of MrTaggy [see reference below for full detail]. We compared the full exploratory MrTaggy interface to a baseline version of MrTaggy that only supported traditional query-based search.

We tested participants’ performance in three different topic domains.

The results show:

(1) Subjects using the MrTaggy full exploratory interface took advantage of the additional features provided by relevance feedback, without giving up their usual manual query typing behavior.

(2) For learning outcomes, subjects using the full exploratory system generally wrote summaries of higher quality compared to baseline system users.

(3) To also gauge learning outcomes, we asked subjects to generate keywords and input as many keywords as possible that were relevant to the topic domain in a certain time limit. Subjects using the exploratory system were generally able to generate more reasonable keywords than the baseline system users.

(4) Finally, other convergent measures show that they also spent more time on the learning tasks, and had a higher cognitive load. Taken together with the higher learning measure outcomes, the users appear to be more engaged in exploration than the participants using the baseline system.

Our findings regarding the use of our exploratory tag search system are promising. The empirical results show that subjects can effectively use data generated by social tagging as “navigational advice” in the learning domain.

The experimental results suggest that users’ explorations in unfamiliar topic areas are supported by the domain keyword recommendations presented in the related tags list and the opportunity for relevance feedback.

Since social search engines that depend on social cues rely on data quality and increasing coverage of the explorable web space, we expect that the constantly increasing popularity of social bookmarking services will improve social search browsers like MrTaggy. The results of this project point to the promise of social search to fulfill a need in providing navigational signposts to the best contents.


Kammerer, Y., Nairn, R., Pirolli, P., and Chi, E. H. 2009. Signpost from the masses: learning effects in an exploratory social tag search browser. In Proceedings of the 27th international Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems (Boston, MA, USA, April 04 - 09, 2009). CHI '09. ACM, New York, NY, 625-634.

ACM Link

Talk Slides


Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Anonymous said...

Sounds promising :)

Maybe the feedback mechanism itself could be directly integrated in the system (using data from online usage) in order to promote successful innovative tools.

Anyway very nice slides, how do you measure "cognitive load" though? Using delayed action in milliseconds or explicit feedback from the user?


PS : eventually those resources could be interesting too
* Stigmergic Optimization, Studies in Computational Intelligence , Vol. 31, 2006 could be interesting too
* Stigmergic Collaboration: The Evolution of Group Work, M/C Journal, Vol. 9, 2006 and his related PhD dissertation

Anonymous said...

and also :

Survival of the fittest tag: Folksonomies, findability, and the evolution of information organization
by Alexis Wichowski

First Monday [Online], Volume 14 Number 5 (8 April 2009)